clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Marlins made J.T. Realmuto multiple lowball extension offers

It’s now easier to understand why the relationship between Realmuto and the club has reached a point of no return: Miami is only willing to pay him about half of his market value.

MLB: Miami Marlins at Philadelphia Phillies Derik Hamilton-USA TODAY Sports

Back in July, 27-year-old catcher J.T. Realmuto was establishing himself as one of baseball’s premier all-around players and welcoming his first child into the world. Seemed like the perfect time for the Marlins to approach him with a contract extension offer, working towards creating a stable, long-term situation for everybody involved. Sure enough, they did, SiriusXM/Five Reasons Sports host Craig Mish reported Monday afternoon.


Mish’s information aligns with a recent scoop from Jon Heyman of Fancred. “Weeks ago the Marlins and Realmuto’s camp talked about a possible extension,” according to Heyman, “and they were so far apart that a trade seems even likelier than before.”

The club offered Salvador Pérez money, the All-Star countered with Buster Posey money. As I explained in July, his true value lies somewhere in the middle.

Presumably, these offers from the Marlins were heavily backloaded. Despite his performance, Realmuto is in a somewhat vulnerable position because he has two remaining years of arbitration eligibility, and a skill set that traditionally gets undervalued by the current system. The MLB Trade Rumors projection model pegs him for a $6.1 million salary in 2019. From there, another terrific season might bump him into the $10-11 million range for 2020.

Even so, these potential extensions attempted to severely discount the subsequent free-agent years (2021 and beyond). Also, the guaranteed terms would’ve only covered his prime; if Realmuto is to forego the opportunity to test the open market, he’d be seeking something closer to a lifetime deal.

One of our Twitter faves Ms. Mambo noted that it’s impossible to reconcile the Marlins’ sky-high asking price in trade talks with these figures that would compensate Realmuto like an average starting catcher. Multiple reports have suggested that they’ve been pressuring other organizations to include their No. 1 prospect as the centerpiece of any potential deal.

The front office hopes that fans will interpret this news as an honest attempt to keep their most recognizable and productive player in Miami. Following Mish’s report, team sources told Fish Stripes that their “final offer” was never presented to Realmuto. His camp “chose not to continue conversing” towards a solution.

That stance is unconvincing.

It’s ultimately in the best interest of both sides to facilitate a trade...assuming that the controllable players who come back in return become building blocks within the Marlins’ window of legitimate contention.