Jorge Sosa (3-1, 2.97) Dontrelle Willis (12-2, 1.76)
So help me, I'm taking Willis tonight. Attendance of 19,954.
By the way, about 80,300 people like Dontrelle Willis (and if you don't somehow reference that when you choose him in ichthyomancy, you'll get no credit for him) In order to understand that reference, you'll have to read this - but be sure to read the comments too (unfortunately the comments don't include permalinks, so you'll have to find the Dontrelle song on your own).
Double B - Willis
Make your picks and discuss...
EDIT: Since I'll be at the ballpark tonight, Craig is in charge.