Marlins first-half awards
With the first-half now complete (plus a week), I thought it would be an opportune time to issue the Fishcrazy First-Half Awards. Your feedback is welcome, especially before the trophies get sent to the engraver and the award checks get printed.
MVP1. Hanley Ramirez (.349/16/61) - Who else? He's the rock in an inconsistent lineup. Earlier this month, he set a team AND NL-shortstop record for most consecutive games with an RBI. He was voted an All-Star starter for the second time, and has rightfully earned pundits' praise as one of the top 3 hitters in the game.
2. Josh Johnson (8-2, 2.74) - What Hanley does for the lineup, JJ does for the pitching staff. Volstad has struggled at times, Nolasco was simply awful for two months, Miller remains an enigma, and Sanchez can't stay healthy and wasn't very good when he was. Through it all, there was JJ, who's thrown less than 6 innings only twice this year.
3. Burke Badenhop (5-3, 3.45) - Yes, it's something of an upset for a long-reliever to be in the MVP conversation. But on a team that's featured imploding starters and a chronically overused bullpen, Badenhop is the guy who performs expert triage. Volstad gets shelled for 8 innings against Boston? Badenhop's there to throw 4+ shutout innings. Anibal gets hurt after 3 innings versus Milwaukee? Badenhop throws <i>five</i> shutout innings. As of right now, he's still the best player we got for Miguel Cabrera.
Honorable mention: Cody Ross (.278/14/52) (solid, but streaky hitter), Kiko Calero (1.95, 32.1 IP, 40 K) (best bullpen arm when healthy)
LVP
1. Matt Lindstrom (6.52 ERA, 14 SV) - No, he's not Jorge Julio-level bad, but he's certainly been a major disappointment. When Gregg was dumped traded, we Fishstripers were delighted that he'd be giving way to the fireballin' Lindstrom. But Lindstrom has been mediocre at best. Opponents are hitting almost .300 off him, and he was pulled from his last save opportunity before going on the DL.
2. Dan Uggla (.227/16/50) - I realize that average isn't everything, and he's been unlucky on balls put in play. But being almost 100 points off his 2008 OPS is more indicative of the problem. He's had his share of homers this year, but hasn't had any sustained hot streaks and is on pace to hit the fewest doubles of his career.
3. Jeremy Hermida (.255/10/34) - Once a top prospect, Hermida was injury-prone and ineffective until he caught fire the second half of '07 and finished at .296. Then he fell back to earth with an inconsequential 2008. So which was the real Hermida? It seems '07 was the fluke: the walks are nice, but he's just not a very good hitter, especially not for a corner outfielder. (There's rumors of him being traded to Pittsburgh for Matt Capps. I'm all for it--let's get Carroll in the lineup.)
Dishonorable Mention - Nolasco (at 2-5 with a 9.07 ERA, he was a shoo-in for LVP, but his terrific rebound pushes him out of the standings); Cameron Maybin (.202/1/3) (he'd be higher, but expectations are scaled back for a 21-year-old-rookie)
CY YOUNG
1. Johnson
2. Badenhop
3. Calero
Honorable mention - Dan Meyer (2-0, 1.78) (see below) Chris Volstad (6-8, 4.44)(the epitome of his up-and-down season: 3 IP/4 ER on July 3, a CG shutout on July 8);
BEST OFFSEASON ACQUISITION
1. Kiko Calero - see above.
2. Ross Gload (.282/3/15) - acquired for a player to be named, Gload's been everything you could want as a veteran off the bench.
3. Dan Meyer - a free-agent pick-up like Kiko, Meyer's been our top lefty all year.
Honorable mention: Ronny Paulino (.241/4/14) (the other half of a solid catching platoon with Baker); Leo Nunez (2-3, 3.79) (bonus points because we got him for Jacobs);
WORST OFFSEASON ACQUISITION
1. Hayden Penn (1-0, 7.77) - we got him for spare parts, but still, he was simply terrible. If only his pitching ability could match his sideburns.
2. Scott Proctor - our medical staff didn't catch this??
3. Emilio Bonifacio - (.258/1/23) - at least he's given us something, unlike the top two. But he's not a net improvement over Olsen or Willingham--heck, not over Willingham alone.
ROOKIE OF THE YEAR
1. Chris Coghlan (.245/2/15) - in a weak crop of rookies, someone's gotta finish first. He's cooled since his average hit .275 in late June, but he's displayed a good eye (30 BB) and has held his own in the outfield. It can't be easy to learn major-league hitting while fielding a new position at the same time.
2. Emilio Bonifacio - Bonifacio has shown some flashes, and he's hitting a little better recently. And we'll always have those first couple of weeks in April. But that's about all I can say for him despite Fredi's adoration.
3. Sean West (3-4, 4.91) - He gave it a go, and was pretty darn good at times (namely, the 8 innings of shutout ball against San Fran). He's still a year away, but has nothing to hang his head about.
0 recs |
8 comments
Comments
No LVP-type award should fail to mention how atrocious Bonifacio has been up to this point in the season. And since his skillset (speed) is what it is, unless he learns some plate patience, there can be no real improvement. He’d have to hit .300+ to even approach a passable OBP.
I think it’s unfair to compare Uggla this season to last year and call his performance poor. He’s been a lot worse, but compared to the rest of the Marlins lineup, he’s been pretty good. He’s the team’s fourth best hitter, can he really be blamed for that? Hermida has been below replacement level thanks to his glove, but I find most people complaining about his bat, which has been around league average. Nevertheless, I won’t defend him any more than that.
by SFiercex4 on Jul 13, 2009 12:33 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
It's a valid point.
Uggla isn’t a flop this year, but he is underperforming. Really, it’s all relative. I based the LVP in large part on expectations. A disaster like Dave Davidson isn’t on the list because I just don’t give him any thought at all. Likewise, I didn’t expect that much from Boner; we thought he’d be a .250 hitter, and he is. I’m not sure the team was ever counting on him the same way it was an Uggla or a Lindstrom.
For his part, Uggla has had a very Jacobs-like season: a bad average, the usual high strikeouts, and a bunch of quiet, non-clutch homers. His homer and RBI totals are still good, but he just hasn’t been very impactful this season. And the lack of doubles is troubling. He’s never hit for average, but he piled up the XBHs. This season, it’s been homer-or-bust with him in that regard.
by Fishcrazy on Jul 13, 2009 1:36 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I can definitely buy that, if you’re judging it by expectations. However, one should point out that even if you expected anything out of Bonifacio, we should not have gotten NOTHING out of him, because that’s he’s offered.
Uggla and Jacobs shouldn’t be in the same sentence. Jake had little value outside of home runs. Uggla has a high OBP that’s been deflated by a poor batting average. And that gets to the luck department. We just have to be patient. I am worried about his doubles, but I’m guessing that might be because he’s hit the ball less solidly than in years past, BABIP luck and such. There should be a few more on his way, but I’ll agree that it has deflated his ISO and power value this season.
by SFiercex4 on Jul 13, 2009 10:23 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Boni isn't a rookie.
He had 157 AB in washington last year. MLB rookie rules says once you have 130 or more in a season you arent a rookie.
also to SFiercex4 you can’t say he’s given us “nothing” when he was a big part in our 11-1 start and also has been turning it around slightly lately on the hitting.
by Fluxuation on Jul 13, 2009 12:42 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
ah, I should've caught that. thanks.
despite spending an hour checking stats, I somehow missed Boni not being a rookie. Well, that immediately removes him from the ROY list. Maybe Brian Sanches takes his place.
by Fishcrazy on Jul 13, 2009 12:53 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
A hot streak doesn’t mean you’re contributing. If a bench player ala Wes Helms gave us a 10-game hot streak and played horrifically the rest of the year, would you really give him all that much credit for the hot streak? Bonifacio has been below replacement level and the worst player on the team. Even if he’s improving right now, it’s yielding bad Juan Pierre at best. I don’t like bad Juan Pierre on my team; normal JP was good enough because of defense.
Hermida belongs in the discussion for worst player, if only because his defense has been so atrocious. But it’s defense, UZR has a +/- 5 run error. wOBA has very little error compared to that, and the sample size is much greater. All of it has said that Bonifacio has been pretty bad.
by SFiercex4 on Jul 13, 2009 10:13 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
How about the Marlins medical staff for LVP?
After totally mishandling Uggla’s injury last year, they’ve done the same thing with Cantu’s this year and he’s yet to recover. Should have DL’d them both, but instead have them play through it.
by BacksThePack on Jul 14, 2009 10:32 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 

















