Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Troubled Yankees Join Troubled Red Sox In Last Place

Dan Uggla can play defense

It sometimes astounds me that people keep writing articles such as the following: (this one courtesy of CBS Sports)

Florida Marlins: How can a team that employs Dan Uggla and Jorge Cantu say with a straight face that it hopes to emphasize run-prevention? In the wake of the Rays' and Phillies' success in 2008, defense is the new black. That's still no reason to consider handing a significant number of at-bats to Emilio Bonifacio, whose contact with pitched balls can only be described as "accidental." It's just the Marlins' luck that none of their clangy infield bashers has the athletic ability to play an outfield corner.

Okay, Cantu is a hack at third base, I won't deny that.  But he does a decent job of playing first.  But I will give Cantu credit, he put the excitement back into the routine ground ball to third.  If he did come up with it cleanly it was always interesting to see where the throw was going to land.

Cantu isn't much of defensive third baseman, or at least he wasn't last season.  But that doesn't mean he doesn't possess some defensive skills.  It just turned out they were better suited across the diamond.

Uggla, on the other hand, did a good job at second.  I have no idea where the author gets his information, but where ever he does it's inaccurate.

If you want to use a lame defensive stat, Fielding Percentage, Danny finished 5th among the qualified 2nd basemen in the NL.  If you would like to get fancier, Uggla finished 6th in RZR and second in OOZ at second base in the NL.

In case you are wondering what RZR and OOZ stands for, let me help.

RZR is the revised zone rating and is the proportion of balls hit into a fielder's zone that he converts to outs.

OOZ is the total number of outs made outside of his zone.

In other words, Danny fielded his position neatly and showed he had some range.

Granted, there are other defensive stats that may be better, but I don't care which ones you choose, none of them will show Danny to be a bad defensive second baseman in 2008.  

That said, you could always go with the only time I watched Uggla was during the All-Star game, so therefore he must be bad.  If that is your metric of choice, then you are a fool.

Comment 5 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Man hold up

Wow! I sense some anger there buddy. Now thats a fan sick and tired of people hating no his team. I feel ya brother!

by TXBoy on Dec 17, 2008 11:39 AM EST reply actions  

dude,

we just traded for a slap-hitting scrub who’s about two notches worse than Amezaga, and all the “analysts” are claiming that he’ll be some kind of improvement because Uggla can’t play defense. It’s a damaging smear that’s become the conventional wisdom, undoubtedly because of the All-Star Game. So yeah, we’re pissed at all the sudden Uggla criticism, and especially by the front office’s complete disrespect to him. Instead of signing him to a long-term deal to be a cornerstone of the franchise, they’re already looking to replace him with speedy .230 hitters.

by Fishcrazy on Dec 17, 2008 3:05 PM EST up reply actions  

He wins most improved

Going from awful to slightly above-average is no small feat. I think the ideal defensive alignment, without knowing too much about who the Marlins plan to start next year, would be 1B Cantu- 2B Uggla- SS Amezaga- 3B Ramirez- LF Ross- CF Maybin- RF Hermida. How close is that to reality?

by Sam Page on Dec 18, 2008 2:19 AM EST reply actions  

Very very close

Amezaga is the best Marlins defensive shortstop but there would be some concern about him wearing down as the season progressed. He did when he was playing center, but center is not shortstop so who knows. If he were prone too, an Amezaga and Andino platoon could get the job done.

Another thing is to put Ross in right and Hermida in left. Ross is by far the better defensive outfielder and given the dimensions of JRS one would want Hermida in the smaller of the two corner outfield slots.

by craig on Dec 18, 2008 10:51 AM EST up reply actions  

Cantu got much better defensively as the season went on and only committed something like three errors from the middle of July through the end of the season. This “bad third baseman” thing is a matter of perception triumphing over reality. You have to think we knows what’s on the line for coming into 2009 and if last season is any indication he’s not above learning from his mistakes.

by UDF2009 on Dec 27, 2008 9:20 AM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Miami Marlins.
Yahoo_full_count

Managers

Doranthumbnail_small Michael Jong

Authors

P5080019_-_copy_small tedhill

Fnf_small FishNFinz

Marlins_small scootertum

Img_0065_small Eric Ely

Jose_reyes__8__small Terrence Hunley

Winstonchurchill_small EricW

330px-marlinsballparkrendring2010_small Brian Mati

Small SamEvans

Headshot_small Zach James